Who will be the Cubs face in the #5 position at the start of the year?
Only 5 days till Spring Training! If all goes well, Lazy Steve, KWil and I (and if God loves the Idiots, Angry Mike as well) will travel to Hohokam Stadium next Wednesday to see the Cub's Spring Training opener. I'm more than excited. This is better than Christmas. And with February 25th being my sister's birthday, who passed away just under 2 years ago, this will give me a day to enjoy instead of get depressed about.
So I haven't posted much about the Cubs lately. I'm sure Angry Mike is cursing me out from Yuma, CA. So in honor of 5 days till Spring Training, I will post something related to the number 5 and the Cubs: the Cubs #5 starter.
It seems everyone wants to be the final piece of the Cubs starting rotation. Of course, if Hendry would have gotten Jake Peavy to join the club (the final thing Zell and the Tribune will do to fuck up the Cubs), we wouldn't be having these discussions. We would basically be counting down the days till the parade from downtown to Wrigley and the award ceremony for the 2009 World Series Champion Chicago Cubs. But alas, I digress.
So here is the final list, as far as I understand (and the
Muskbag reports):
Sean Marshall
Chad Gaudin
Jeff Samardzija
Mitch Atkins
Aaron Heilman
This differs a little bit from the original list I posted as a poll in our sidebar which also included Kevin Hart, Rich Hill (gone) and Juan Guzman, although did not include Chad Gaudin, Mitch Atkins or Aaron Heilman (I guess my poll is a little out of date).
Here are the results from your votes:

and a more updated poll from
the Bleacher Report:

Just as Lou has stated, you guys voted Sean Marshall as the number one contender for the #5 position. And it makes sense. Marshall is lefty who has shown he can start. But here's my take, albeit a probably uninformed and pointless one:
Mitch Atkins
This is seriously what the dude looks like. You want him starting every 5th day?
Who? The guy doesn't even have a Wikipedia page I can reference.
Chad Gaudin
A team cannot have too many Frenchmen. Oh wait, yes it can. Gaudin came over from the A's last year as the cherry on top of the Harden sundae (mmm...sundaes!). We saw a little of him in relief before he got shit-faced, tried to make love to a garbage dumpster and threw out his back in the process. Gaudin was a starter for the A's in 2007 and made 34 appearances and just under 200 innings pitched with a mid 4 era.
My take: Gaudin seemed to have good "stuff" although at times was out of control, which worries me that if he can't get it together in the first or second innings it would stretch out our mid-relievers (who worry me even more). Plus even though Gaudin has started before, he is still really young. If he would be able to learn from the veteran staff, he would have a chance down the road, but I don't like him to start the beginning of the season.
Positives: Durable (until that back thingy)
Negatives: Right-handed, young, wild.
Bonus points for the pretty sweet goatee-beard he's sporting this spring.
Aaron Heliman
Only the real thing, baby! Heilman came over from the Mets via the Mariners. Because he is new, I have no actual memories of him pitching. So let's look at the stats on the intraweb. Heilman hasn't started since 2005 and hasn't been a regular in a rotation since 2004. Last year with the Mets, he was 3-8 with a 5.21 ERA in 78 games.
My take: I really don't have one, besides I like mayonnaise, and Heilman's is by far my favorite brand. All kidding aside, looking at those stats, I don't know why we picked the guy up. He's another righty in an overcrowded middle-relief quandary that Hendry has assembled. We saw that with some hard work, a reliever can return to the starting role in Dumpster last year (please prove to us that wasn't fluke you damn Canuck). Is Heilman the next Dempster?
Positives: Durable, experienced, "Chicago" native
Negatives: Hasn't been in regular rotation since 2004, right-handed
Jeff Samardzija
Jeff gets all the ladies. Look at Sean Marshall. Poor Sean.
Samardz...Jeff was a great wide receiver for the Fighting Irish, but chose to follow baseball instead, signing one of the highest minor league deals I can remember. He moved up quickly through the minor league system last year, despite never actually proving himself at any level. He claims to have four pitches, although a slightly above average fastball and mediocre slider are really his only "effective" ones. Jeff was 1-0 with a 2.28 ERA and one save in 26 games as a reliever last year for the Cubs.
My take:The guy has been a starter his entire career (well, all 3 years plus college) and that makes it easy for him to step into the role, rather than try to re-learn and train for it like Gaudin or Heilman will have to. His fastball is pretty good, if he can control it, and plus he went to Notre Dame! He is still really young though, but has experience in pressure situations through his footballing career at Notre Dame (did I mention he went to Notre Dame?) If he builds an effective 3rd pitch, he would be decent as a starter that could give you a good 6-7 innings.
Positives: Good work ethic, firey, Notre Dame grad
Negatives: Young, only 1 good pitch, right-handed
Which leaves us with...
Sean Marshall
insert funny caption here...
Marshall has been a work-horse for the Cubs, and it hasn't gone unnoticed. It's not a secret that Cub blogs want Marshall to start, and Lou agrees: "I like Marshall a lot. He's always done what the organization wanted, and he's improving. He gotten stronger, and I feel extremely comfortable with him as my number five starter," said Cubs third year manager Lou Piniella. Plus he is left-handed. Bonus!
My take:I really like Marshall. Unlike
Marquis de Suc last year, Marshall understands he will have to compete for the #5 position, even though he is the favorite. But Sean has never complained, whether Lou throws him out to start a game to help a guy get a break in the rotation, or asks him to clean up someone's mess by throwing him in with 3 men on, and 4 runs down in the 2nd inning as a long reliever. Marshall has earned the job, and as stated by Lou and the media, it's his job to lose.
Positives: Left-handed, work-horse, proven starter
Negatives: Leaves only Cotts in the bullpen as the lone lefty

Here is my problem with Marshall:
Neil Fucking Cotts. I hate seeing Cotts as the only left-handed reliever in the pen. He has proven that he can't do shit besides give up runs. Last year I saw give up a home run in Tucson that went so far it hit the parking lot, something I heard veteran spectators say they have never seen before. Leaving Cotts in the bullpen as the only lefty is a recipe for disaster, especially in close games. Keep Marshall in the pen, but only because he provides a reliable left-handed middle reliever. Plus, as he did last year, he can provide that needed in-between starts for the rest of our rotation, especially Harden.
My thoughts are go with Heilman, but probably because I haven't seen how bad he actually is. He once had stuff, but then again so did Gaudin. Move Samarjammamama down to triple A to keep him working on his third pitch, and if he effectively produces one, bring him back up as the 5th starter. Or just get Jake Peavy early in the year, and it won't be an issue anymore.
So there you go, an actual post about the Cubs. That's my opinion, and I'm sticking to it.
Go Cubs!

Share on
Facebook. Follow us on
Twitter.